In the opening of Twilight Zone: The Movie (1983), two guys are driving down a dark, empty highway in the middle of the night, singing along to the radio. Then the driver turns to his passenger and asks, “Do you want to see something really scary?”
He switches off the headlights. Nothing but black in every direction.
Now do you want to hear something really scary?
You’re new on the job, and you’ve been handed “the website.”
One morning the website is down. You start digging and find an overdue domain notice, an account you can’t log into, and a former employee’s email on file. While you’re still trying to figure out who to call, the clock runs out.
Soon you type in your company’s web address and there’s a stranger’s page sitting where yours used to be. They’re squatting at your address, and it’s a good chance they’re holding it ransom. They’re offering to sell it back to you, but at a much higher price than before, often thousands of dollars. And to make it even more threatening, they could direct your customers to undesirable content to damage your reputation.
This happens, and it could happen to you.
Cue the creepy music.
The Website That Vanished Overnight
Over the years, we’ve seen this happen to several organizations: Their website unexpectedly disappeared.
But it wasn’t just gone; someone else had moved in.
Their domain—the www. address customers had typed and bookmarked for years—now took people to an empty site, a “parked” site, or worse…to a site that had nothing to do with their family-friendly business. Let’s just say it was not the kind of content you’d want your grandmother, or your customers, stumbling onto.
No hacker in a hoodie. No elaborate cyberattack. Just an easy-to-miss door left unlocked allowing the domain snatchers in.
How Does This Happen?
Most of the time, it comes down to one misunderstanding: your domain name and your website are two separate things.
Think of it this way: Your website is your house. Your domain name is your street address. If you let the domain expire and someone else acquires it, your house might still be standing, but they now control where your address takes people.
They could send visitors to their own website, a competitor, or something worse. And the address printed on your business cards, signs, and brochures now leads wherever they choose.
Here’s how it usually unfolds:
- Your domain name comes up for renewal. Domains are rented, not owned. You pay every year, or every 2 to 10 years, depending on what you signed up for.
- The payment card on file has expired. Nobody updated it, so the renewal quietly fails.
- The warning emails go nowhere. They land in an old inbox, a spam folder, or the account of someone who left your organization.
- The grace period runs out. Most registrars give you a window, often about 30 days, to update your card and renew. After that, recovery gets expensive, and eventually impossible.
- The domain is released. Automated services snatch up expired domains within minutes, especially ones with existing traffic. Yours had traffic.
How to Keep the Lights On
The good news: this is completely preventable. Fifteen minutes today can save you a nightmare later.
- Find out where your domain lives. Search your domain on a WHOIS lookup site (like whois.com or lookup.icann.org) to see the registrar and the expiration date.
- Make sure the account belongs to the business. Register it in the company’s name, not a former employee’s or your nephew who “does computers.”
- Use a shared email for the account. Something like [email protected], so renewal notices reach whoever holds the job, not whoever held it three years ago.
- Turn on auto-renew. Also add a backup payment method if your registrar allows it.
- Renew for multiple years. Many registrars let you prepay up to 10 years. Fewer renewals means fewer chances to miss one.
- Turn on registrar lock and two-factor login. This keeps anyone from transferring your domain away without permission.
- Put renewal dates on a shared calendar. Set a reminder 60 days out, so there’s time to fix problems.
- Store logins in a password manager. Domain, hosting, and website admin, all in one place the business controls.
- Add the website to your onboarding and off-boarding checklist. When someone joins or leaves, the domain, hosting, and logins get handed off on purpose.
Don’t Wait for the Twist Ending
In The Twilight Zone, nobody sees the twist coming. That’s fun on TV, but not where you want to live.
If you’re not sure where your domain is registered, when it renews, or whose email is on the account, this is your sign to find that out today. And if you’d rather not go poking around in the dark, just reach out. At Artmil, we’re happy to look up where your domain stands and make sure it’s set to renew.
Because the only thing scarier than losing your website is finding out there was a simple way to keep the website snatchers out.